Caution urged as free financial advice service launched

Author: Scott Sinclair
IFAonline | 12 Mar 2010 | 12:30

Categories: Better Business

Topics: RDR

phone-mouthpiece-big-jpg

A Government scheme providing members of the public with access to free face-to-face ‘independent’ financial advice is being rolled out nationwide.

Moneymadeclear, described by the FSA as effectively the "brand name" for Money Guidance, includes access to a helpline, website and face-to-face advice services.

The FSA says "fully trained" individuals will be on hand to offer basic financial "guidance" for telephone and in-person customers, which will be available from next month following a successful pilot in the North East.

Chancellor Alistair Darling says the cost of the service, which it expects will help about a million people in the next year, will be funded by a levy on the financial sector and funds recovered from dormant bank accounts, with the Government meeting part of the cost in the first year.

Delivered through partners including Citizens Advice and Age Concern, Darling says people will get access to free advice on money worries, financial planning, or advice on their rights and actions they can take if they feel they are not getting a fair deal.

Many fully-fledged financial advisers welcome the Money Guidance initiative - the brainchild of a project led by Aegon chief executive Otto Thoresen - but argue the FSA's RDR is unnecessarily disenfranchising consumers from access to paid-for but in-depth advice services.

"Moneymadeclear is free, impartial advice for all, whether you are unsure about the small print in a mortgage form; want advice about opening a savings account for your children or grandchildren or you want some help dealing with repayments before they get out of hand," Darling says.

The ABI cautions consumers the Moneymadeclear scheme will only serve those with the most basic financial needs.

"If they need specific advice, the new service will only be able to offer general advice," ABI director of life and savings Maggie Craig says.

"As part of our work on the RDR, the ABI is working on a new financial advice service, known as simplified advice. This would be for consumers who are unable to afford or do not require full advice, and will complement Moneymadeclear."

 

More better business news

Recommended reading

Categories

Topics

Comments

This shows a complete failure of regulation

Over a decade of regulation by the FSA which was set up to "protect the consumer". We have had every rule, regulation, fees, and costs that anyone could possibly think of and now we have to pay for a financial advice service to help consumers get "free" advice. Is this by any chance because it is now so expensive for any firm to give advice due to the ever increasing costs and incompetence of our regulatory system? How good is this "free advice" going to be and who do they complain to if it turns out to be poor? This can hardly be considered progress when we now have to fund on a "charitable basis" the giving of "free advice" because many now cannot afford or do not want to pay for advice due to the actions of the very people and organisations that were set up to protect the very same consumers !! When will it all end I wonder ? Soon we will need a "free advice" service for advisers on how to get help because of the FSA ? Time we had a vote of "no confidence" in the FSA as that is about all we can do seeing as they are protected from being sued or otherwise for any mistakes they make even though we pay them to do the job they repeatedly fail to do. Our wallets are open yet we have no say or control of what they do they just keep dipping into them regardless of their own failings or responsibilities

Posted by: Michael Fallas

12 Mar 2010 | 13:26
Complain about this comment

Great Idea

Its funny but just this morning I was discussing with a colleague what happened to all the old IB and OB policys that used to cost a few pounds a month. The reality of the modern fully regulated financial world is that there are millions of people out there who feel they cannot talk to financial advisers and advisers that cannot afford to talk to them. Anything that gives them at least a degree of help in managing their money can only be a good thing.

Posted by: Kev S

12 Mar 2010 | 13:31
Complain about this comment

Fantastic

This is exactly what we need to help get this country out of recession, more public sector jobs at the expense of the private sector. I love Labours ideas on job creation. Can I join the Superann scheme?

Posted by: Tom Evans

12 Mar 2010 | 13:55
Complain about this comment

The National Finance Service is Born!

Similar to the National Health Service it offers General Practioners, (IFA's) paid £260,000 p.a. by the state, the ability to assist the general public with their finances for free. To provide that all important base level of assistance. Oh sorry I just woke up and it was all a dream! Snigger

Posted by: www.MortgageShop.com

12 Mar 2010 | 14:03
Complain about this comment

Come back Lewis Carroll. all is forgiven

Talk about Alice in Blunderland. So the phone will be answered by "fully trained" advisers. Not fully qualified, I notice. So, to be on a level playing field, can I now go beyond 2012 without Level 4. Of course not, but I will still have to pay for them. Very Red Queen. "Anything can mean whatever I say it means". So where is the free advice service on legal and tax matters, paid for by Solicitors and Accountants? Of course it will not happen as they are self regulating professions and don't have the FSA monkey on their backs.

Posted by: Mike Hillier

12 Mar 2010 | 14:36
Complain about this comment

Winey advisers ??!!

I assume I am being accused as are others of being a "winey sales advisor" Well I would dispute that description and I have offered my cleints fees based advice for 20 years but for me the issue here is why we are paying for this and indeed why after the most onerous regulation of any western country we have made no progress in educating the public on financial matters or indeed encouraging them to save. Much of this I blame on an incompetant regulator and I am all for better financial education for everyone, I would however prefer it to be with those who have the experience and have the necessary skills to provide ongoing advice and not be a short stop low cost solution. This does not solve the real problem. It is like plugging a leak but is not a long term solution.

Posted by: Michael Fallas

12 Mar 2010 | 15:40
Complain about this comment

Another Charity

This is not free advice. The advisers are paid by someone. This is either a Charity, that should be regulated by the Charity Commissioners, or a Government Department. What legal powers are there for raising the money from the sources stated to pay for this service. And will those providing the advice be required to take exams, be regulated by the FSA, and provide all the background administration that IFAs are required to provide? There is certainly a gap in the market that needs to be filled, but fragmenting the market further seems a strange way of providing the solution.

Posted by: Glen McKeown

12 Mar 2010 | 17:25
Complain about this comment

Another Charity

This is not free advice. The advisers are paid by someone. This is either a Charity, that should be regulated by the Charity Commissioners, or a Government Department. What legal powers are there for raising the money from the sources stated to pay for this service. And will those providing the advice be required to take exams, be regulated by the FSA, and provide all the background administration that IFAs are required to provide? There is certainly a gap in the market that needs to be filled, but fragmenting the market further seems a strange way of providing the solution.

Posted by: Glen McKeown

12 Mar 2010 | 17:25
Complain about this comment

Precious metals

Bet they won't be recommending gold or silver as a good investment. This service is linked to gov't who don't want competition for their paper funny money.

Posted by: very sceptical

14 Mar 2010 | 11:14
Complain about this comment

To About Time

It is interesting to see that you are so proud to support this initiative that you are too embarassed to add your own name to the support for it............. If you have the courage of your convictions, then stand by them, otherwise your opinion is pretty worthless.... And for the record, i have not decided whether this initiative is a good or a bad thing, but I certainly will not look on it favourably if those who support it are cowards.

Posted by: Phil Castle

15 Mar 2010 | 08:48
Complain about this comment

Open your eyes !

re : accountants and solicitors : We have had free advice lines provided by HMRC for a long time,they do not advise just read the HMRC information sheets. And the additional business link disaster, of failed business men advising business, these guys think they know everything and are a thorn... My point is that the entire system of advice is under threat! This government believes in state control but expects the private sector to pay for it. The entire dumbing down process and oppressive legislation is occuring everywhere!! Open your eyes !

Posted by: Spike

15 Mar 2010 | 09:36
Complain about this comment

Related articles

Most Read

Audio / Visual

Coffee Lounge

View all the winners here

PPR Structured Product Awards 2011

View all the winners here

This year we have 14 awards designed to mark out the very best products in a highly competitive and innovative market. This includes three new awards for 2011 to reflect the developments in this rapidly growing market: Best Dual/Multi-Index Product, Best Structured (Oeic) Fund and Best Structured Product Provider.

Events

event logo

fund5live

21 Feb 2012 - 29 Feb 2012

London, UK

event logo

COVER Breakfast Briefing: Cash Plans

27 Mar 2012 - 27 Mar 2012

London, UK

event logo

Buy to Let Market Forum

17 Apr 2012 - 18 Apr 2012

London, UK

Poll

Should there be a cap on hourly fees?

Viewpoints